'He should retire now' – Mexican media criticize Javier 'Chicharito' Hernández for poor form and off-field issues

The veteran striker has scored just three goals in 34 appearances since returning to Chivas

  • This is his fourth season with the club
  • He didn’t play in Matchday 1 against León
  • His contract reportedly won’t be renewed

'He should retire now' - Mexican media criticize Javier 'Chicharito' Hernández for poor form and off-field issues'He should retire now' - Mexican media criticize Javier 'Chicharito' Hernández for poor form and off-field issues'He should retire now' - Mexican media criticize Javier 'Chicharito' Hernández for poor form and off-field issues'He should retire now' - Mexican media criticize Javier 'Chicharito' Hernández for poor form and off-field issues'He should retire now' - Mexican media criticize Javier 'Chicharito' Hernández for poor form and off-field issues

The recent controversy surrounding Javier ‘Chicharito’ Hernández’s sexist remarks has amplified the criticism he’s faced in recent months since returning to his boyhood club, Chivas, after a successful run in Europe and MLS. His second stint has been widely disappointing: just three goals in 34 matches, with little playing time under the various coaches who’ve managed the now 37-year-old striker.

Despite being ‘s all-time leading scorer and one of the most accomplished Mexican players to have played in Europe, Hernández has continued to benefit from a level of respect. But with his poor performances and now his off-field controversy – which led to fines from Chivas and the Mexican Football Federation – critics are urging him to step aside.

Among those critics is seven-time champion Ricardo ‘Tuca’ Ferretti, now an analyst at ESPN, who had a blunt message: “He should retire now – he should leave football, not let football leave him.”

“I thought this season would go well for him because he had time for a proper preseason,” Ferretti added. “But he had surgery early on, then another issue, and then he pulled something during warm-up. It’s all taking a toll.”

Ferretti says Chivas should not renew his deal after the Apertura 2025 and urged Hernández to protect his legacy: “Because of all the injuries and his current situation, he should really consider retiring. We remember him as a great player in Europe – , , Leverkusen, the team. Let’s not ruin that image.”

On FOX Sports, former striker Carlos Hermosillo said Hernández no longer fits into Milito’s system and drew a parallel with his own retirement: “I left when I felt I couldn’t perform anymore – I didn’t want to sit on the bench.”

Eduardo de la Torre recalled that he considered retirement at 31 due to physical issues and urged Chicharito to do the same: “It’s time to give others a chance.”

According to FOX Sports Mexico, Chivas does not plan to offer Hernández a new deal when his contract ends this season. Chicharito is currently dealing with a calf issue from his last appearance and is questionable for this weekend’s match, depending on whether he joins full training.

It’s worth noting that Hernández arrived at Chivas with a torn ACL from his time in MLS, delaying his debut in Liga MX. Since then, he’s suffered an ankle injury, multiple muscle strains, a knee sprain, and other knocks that have affected his performance.

In 2025, he’s dealt with a fresh ankle issue, a facial injury, recurring calf problems, and more muscle-related setbacks. The result? Just three goals in 34 games.

At Chivas, the all-time leading scorer for the Mexican national team earns an annual salary of $2.5 million.

The Red and Whites will host Atlético de San Saturday in Matchday 3.